Thanks, all! Here's the tree so far: familyecho.com/?p=START&c=4ozc21smcj&f=665176630774159696. I haven't included any of the original DuckTales Beagles, (except for Ma Beagle, because I wasn't sure who else to put for the Beagle Boys' mother), because I don't consider the original DuckTales canon to the comics (I like it a lot, and I consider most things canon to the comics, but it just doesn't seem to fit in). Anyway, it otherwise includes most of the Beagles that I could find, but I'll probably update it with more soon.
Thanks, all! Here's the tree so far: familyecho.com/?p=START&c=4ozc21smcj&f=665176630774159696. I haven't included any of the original DuckTales Beagles, (except for Ma Beagle, because I wasn't sure who else to put for the Beagle Boys' mother), because I don't consider the original DuckTales canon to the comics (I like it a lot, and I consider most things canon to the comics, but it just doesn't seem to fit in). Anyway, it otherwise includes most of the Beagles that I could find, but I'll probably update it with more soon.
Oh, and another interesting one you could add is Great-Grandpappy Beagle number 1, from this funny story: inducks.org/story.php?c=W+BB+++23-01 During the Junior Woodchuck "Boss-for-a-day" event, Scrooge has to trade placed with his lowest-ranked employees: the Beagle Boys. However, soon after the Beagle Boys get their hands on Scrooge's fortune, however, Duckburg gets flooded with their countless relatives, who all want their cut, and among them is their wise great-grandfather, Number 1, the eldest Beagle Boys member.
Attachments:
Last Edit: Jan 31, 2018 13:01:38 GMT by Scroogerello
Oh, and another interesting one you could add is Great-Grandpappy Beagle number 1, from this funny story: inducks.org/story.php?c=W+BB+++23-01 During the Junior Woodchuck "Boss-for-a-day" event, Scrooge has to trade placed with his lowest-ranked employees: the Beagle Boys. However, soon after the Beagle Boys get their hands on Scrooge's fortune, however, Duckburg gets flooded with their countless relatives, who all want their cut, and among them is their wise great-grandfather, Number 1, the eldest Beagle Boys member.
In the scan I posted above (from the Greek reprint) the ghost is clearly referred to as a great-grandpa. Checking the scans on Inducks and with my little knowledge of French I can see the same happened on Journal de Mickey and also on the Dutch reprint of the story.
So I presume that was the intention of the author and since the story has not been published in English speaking countries I cannot understand where the name Scary Beagle came from in the description.
On older stories, some Inducks descriptions came from Egmont.
I've seen this story in its original version, though (when considering it for an IDW issue), and can confirm that Scary Beagle is the character's name, and that he's presented as our "original" BBs' great-grandpa.
Okay, I've added a few more relatives, including the ones mentioned on this thread since I posted the first link, and a few others I've found. The new version can still be accessed from the old link, but for convenience, here it is again: familyecho.com/?p=START&c=iduo0g8wpd&f=665176630774159696
Okay, I've added a few more relatives, including the ones mentioned on this thread since I posted the first link, and a few others I've found. The new version can still be accessed from the old link, but for convenience, here it is again: familyecho.com/?p=START&c=iduo0g8wpd&f=665176630774159696
Why do you disregard Blackheart and Grandpa Beagle being the same character? It doesn't contradict anything, forces one to disregard most Don Rosa stories if ignored, and it's a pretty well-accepted fact by now (consider how often recent stories and translations have referred to the white-beared Grandpa Beagle as "Blackheart"). Not to mention, having Ma Beagle be a Beagle by birth and her husband be a Beagle too seems very questionable by Disney standards…
Oh, one thing I noticed about the tree: "Supersensitive" Beagle (whom you placed on the tree as the Beagle Boys's cousin), is actually their brother, according to his debut story: inducks.org/story.php?c=W+BB++++3-04 .
Also, the Beagle Brats are brothers, as well (not cousins). As for other additions to the tree, I'm quite sure the Beagle Boys had triplet nieces as well in some older W-coded stories, but I can't find the stories they appeared in.
Scrooge MacDuck: I don't disregard them as being the same person, it's just that I wanted to have there be a grandfather on both sides of the tree, so I treated them as separate characters. Also, I intended the two Beagle families to be separate families with the same surname
Scroogerello: Is there any story where it is mentioned that they are siblings? If there is, I'll change it. I did it like that to distinguish them from HDL and April May and June, because it's probably unlikely that there are that many identical triplets in one town. (though in my headcanon, AMJ are fraternal triplets). Anyway, thanks for the tip about the triplet nieces.