Post by mkr on Sept 1, 2023 14:57:02 GMT
In the recently published H 2023-136, Elvira talks about her uncle Zacharias Duck, a racing legend. He is also seen in a flashback. Scans here.
Is Paperonk considered to be a given name or a family name?
In some of the Paperut stories there is also a Ludwig look-a-like. Paperut calls him uncle in the German translation of I TL 2549-6. Scan here. Is he also an uncle in the Italian version? And what is his Italian name?
That's not necessary. I have a scan of her. But does she have a name in the Italian version?
Pretty much all of the portraits have been disregarded currently because they're unnamed and whatnot - but, from some pictures I found online (Posted by Xanderares I believe), there's one named "Paperello da Messin".I was actually planning to add many of these unnamed portraits for the next update of the tree. But I hadn't noticed that one of them had a name. Thanks!
UPDATE: I checked the story, and the name given here is is supposed to be the name of the painter.
They were discussed previously, but dismissed because they weren't stated to be ancestors in the story, but in an external article. Since we're pretty solidly accepting supporting articles now, I feel like they should probably be addedI am aware of this one and maybe it should be added, though there was some doubt if this should be considered canon. In the post by farmspirit when it was discussed (this post), it is also mentioned that this type of article isn't an isolated event, but it is repeated for various stories in different volumes. So accepting this one, might result in accepting relatives from many other stories as well, though I don't know which ones.
Do you have any scans of the issue? Mainly just anything that specifies it as a past life and, if possible, scans of Donaldo himselfScan from the Donaldo story here.
Operating on that logic, we can confirm that Paperonk is an ancestor, as well as the following:
Paperut (No direct reference, but would presumably be Donald's ancestor)
Do you need scans of Il Corsaro Nero's niece?
Also, side-note - I was checking a few details, and something came up regarding I TL 2116-4.
Pretty much all of the portraits have been disregarded currently because they're unnamed and whatnot - but, from some pictures I found online (Posted by Xanderares I believe), there's one named "Paperello da Messin".
UPDATE: I checked the story, and the name given here is is supposed to be the name of the painter.
I TL 2477-4 features the Paperier cousins, as well as Paperon de'Papergnac.
They were discussed previously, but dismissed because they weren't stated to be ancestors in the story, but in an external article. Since we're pretty solidly accepting supporting articles now, I feel like they should probably be added
As That Duckfan mentioned, the past lives are relevant, at least depending on one's point of view - not necessarily needed to be added to the tree, but I want to document them in the index when possible
Do you have any scans of the issue? Mainly just anything that specifies it as a past life and, if possible, scans of Donaldo himself